Monday, June 8, 2009
Zebras
Can a zebra really change its stripes? Desmond Tutu writes in his book "No Future Without Forgiveness" that the horrors of apartheid could only be worked past with forgiveness on both sides. This seemed to work well enough, but where's the justice? Is justice just a flawed concept we came up with to satisfy our own egomaniacal sense of self worth? If so, then where does that put god in all this? I once had a friend say that only god could grant forgiveness...and that friend is an atheist...does this mean by that logic there is no such thing as forgiveness in the world? And if there is, who is to deem who is worthy of it? The victim? What if both parties are the victim? How does one forgive themself? I think that one's the hardest of them all. How does a man of upstanding moral character (permanant or newfound) decide when he is worthy of being forgiven for his past misgivings? Even in acting in the role of the aggressor, he would still remember the sins of the past and get this sinking feeling in the pit of his stomach. This would all also lead him to question the existance of god, in whatever form he believed him to be. How could he still feel so terrible about all he had done, and furthermore hate himself when there is THE source of forgiveness right there wittnessing his sorrow for his crimes? When does it become ok to see yourself as a decent person when your vision is forever clouded by the memory of your evil? Not any answers here, doubt I'll find any out there either.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Your friend doesnt sound like a very good atheist. Were they trying to suggest that forgivness doesnt exist since there is no god?
ReplyDeleteFor me, forgivness comes when you realize that dwelling on the mistakes of the past doesnt get you or the "victim" anywhere. Steeping in the agnst of things you've done has no purpose and will get you nothing. It is easy to get bogged down by all the mistakes we make...smarter to acknowledge them and move on with things.
Yeah, the implication was there of a gaping void where the deity/forgiveness should be. The main issue with myself is that I'm truly trying to change who I am on more than a superficial level, and with that comes the doubt I physically cannot forgive myself for everything I've done whether the others involved have or not. I'm also being led to question my beliefs in a higher power lately, wondering if the universe really is just a cold, unforgiving equation. I guess this is what happens when you start reading too many scientific publications...and re-reading "the origin of species" aint helping either...
ReplyDeleteoops...double negative in there...sue me, I'm typing this shit before work...you know what I'm trying to say, bitches!
ReplyDeleteI am probably the wrong person to give advice about losing your religion (dont bother asking REM either) but here i go anyway...
ReplyDelete"What I see in Nature is a magnificent structure that we can comprehend only very imperfectly, and that must fill a thinking person with a great feeling of humility." -Einstein
I agree that the universe is cold and unforgiving, but i dont think a belief in god is what gives us the humility and awe that we are seeking. When you take god out of the picture, human life is so much more amazing and awe inspiring. All that we have learned, all that we have built and created...everything "man made" in this world developing from clusters of cells that have evolved over millions and millions of years. Language and art and music...novels and poems and science.
Removing the belief in god allows us to see each other as we are. Humans, in this together with nothing but outselves to rely on. Scary? Yes. Beautiful? I think so.